Choosing a contractor on more than cost and time

Back to the blog

Suppose two quotes come back within a few hundred dollars and a few days of each other. Most people then pick on price, because it is the only number left. That is usually the wrong call, because the things that separate those two contractors are not on the quote at all.

Depth of experience with your specific work

Not years in business — relevance. Someone who has done thirty of your job knows where the problems hide. Someone doing their first is competent and learning, and learning happens on your house at your expense.

Who does the work

Ask whether the crew is employed or subcontracted, and whether the same people will be there throughout. Neither answer is wrong. An employed crew tends to mean consistency and direct control. Subcontracted specialists can mean higher skill in each trade and more coordination risk.

What you want to avoid is not knowing, because that usually means it will be whoever is free.

How they handle being wrong

This is the single most useful thing to probe and the hardest to ask directly. Try: tell me about a job that went wrong and what you did about it.

Someone who describes a real problem and what they changed afterwards is telling you how they will behave when it happens on yours. Someone who claims nothing has ever gone wrong is either inexperienced or not being straight with you.

Financial stability

An uncomfortable subject and a material one. A contractor in cash flow trouble uses your deposit to finish someone else's job, and yours gets funded by the next customer. Eventually someone is left short.

Signals: pressure for a large deposit, reluctance to tie payments to milestones, unusual eagerness for immediate cash. A stable business can wait for a milestone.

Communication style, matched to yours

Some contractors send photos daily. Some think you are checking up on them. Neither is wrong, but a mismatch produces friction for the whole project.

Say what you want at the start. "A short update at the end of each week, and a call if anything unexpected comes up" is a reasonable request, and how someone responds to it tells you whether it will happen.

Willingness to disagree with you

A contractor who tells you your idea will not work is worth more than one who agrees with everything. You are hiring expertise. If they never contradict you, you are only hiring hands.

What their references say about problems

Ask references what went wrong and how it was handled. Every project has something. A reference who says nothing ever went wrong either had an unusually smooth job or is not being candid.

Whether they are still around in three years

Workmanship warranties are only worth the business behind them. A contractor with a long local history and a licence in good standing is more likely to answer the phone when something surfaces later.

How to weigh it

When price and schedule are close, rank on: relevant experience, quality of the quote, how they behave during quoting, references on problems, and financial signals. Price breaks the tie rather than leading the decision.

On a small job, price can lead. On anything structural, anything involving water, or anything you will live with daily for years, it should not.