How to get good quality work, not just finished work

Back to the blog

Nobody sets out to do a bad job. Poor quality is rarely a matter of someone not caring. It usually comes from one of three things: nobody specified what good looked like, the schedule did not allow for it, or nobody checked until it was too late to correct.

Specify it, or you will get the default

Every trade has a normal standard and a higher one, and the difference is often invisible in a quote. Tile can be laid to a tolerance that looks fine from standing height or one that looks right from a foot away. Paint can be one coat over patched drywall or properly primed. Both are "painting the room".

If you have not said which you want, you will get the one that matches the price, and that is not unfair.

Quality has a schedule cost, and you have to allow it

Several parts of construction cannot be rushed without a visible price. Mortar cures. Paint needs recoat time. Wood flooring should acclimate before installation. Concrete gains strength on its own timetable.

A contractor under time pressure will compress somewhere, and it is usually the invisible waiting rather than the visible work. If you have pushed hard on the schedule, you have implicitly chosen this trade.

Inspect at the right moments, not constantly

Daily hovering makes crews defensive and does not catch much. Inspection at the points where the next step covers up the last one catches almost everything.

• After demolition, before anything new goes in, when the existing conditions are visible.
• After rough plumbing and electrical, before drywall. This is the single most valuable look.
• After substrate and waterproofing, before tile.
• Before final payment, walking the whole job with a list.

The rough-in inspection matters most because everything behind that drywall becomes expensive to reach. Ten minutes with a phone camera at that stage is worth more than any amount of later scrutiny.

Take photographs of everything hidden

Before drywall goes up, photograph the walls. Pipe runs, wiring, blocking, insulation. It costs nothing and it is invaluable when someone needs to drill a hole in three years, or when a leak appears and nobody knows what is behind that wall.

Understand what the inspector does and does not do

A building inspector checks compliance with code. Code is a minimum safety standard, not a quality standard. Work can pass inspection and still be sloppy, because passing means it will not hurt anyone, not that it was done well.

Your own inspection is for quality. The city's is for safety. They are not substitutes.

The punch list, done properly

At the end, walk the job and write down everything that needs attention. Be specific and unemotional: "chip in the tile grout, left of the vanity" rather than "bathroom needs finishing".

Do it before the final payment, because that is the only moment when everyone's incentives point the same way. Agree a date for the items and hold the final payment until they are done.

Say what is good, too

This sounds soft and it is practical. Crews doing careful work on a home project rarely hear about it. A contractor who knows you notice the difference between adequate and good is more likely to keep giving you good.